Only one game tonight, and that's not expected to be too much of a contest. BYU is playing their second consecutive Friday game and hoping for their second consecutive Friday win.
Congratulations to LucklessWonder, a new entrant from last week, who spotted most other players a week's worth of points and is now on a charge to catch up.
Rank
Player
W - L
Pts
1
nobiology
16-4
94
2
Foreigner
16-4
90
3
ed315
13-7
88
4
georgehr
15-5
87
5
TFG
14-6
84
6
RBA
14-6
82
7
tommyallenn
13-7
79
8
LucklessWonder
7-13
47
9
eadams928
6-14
40
10
rockhopper
6-14
33
11
Deadpool
6-14
31
12
theleftybarber
3-17
12
Neither algorithm is going to dominate in any given week, but consistency is the name of the game. We're fine always being third and fourth in a given week if it means that different people rotate around as first as second. In the end we'll simply pull ahead.
We've also re-run the numbers after two weeks' worth of play and have tweaked the original point projections. Here they are:
[ Note: Justin is on the road this week and won't have much to say about his games. ]
Week 4 is in the books, so let's look at the recap of our games of the week.
Week 4
System
Expected
Actual
W - L
Win %
W - L
Win %
TFG
34.6 - 12.4
73.6
34 - 13
72.3
RBA
33.8 - 13.2
71.9
34 - 13
72.3
Game of the Week
LSU Tigers 47, West Virginia Mountaineers 21
Justin
(5) LSU 33, (21) West Virginia 29 (64.2%)
The final score was actually less close than the actual game, which saw four West Virginia turnovers that yielded 21 points for LSU. If the Mountaineers hold onto the ball a bit better, then the game becomes much more interesting. As it was, LSU completely dominated and will look to rise in the rankings this week.
Eddie
(17) West Virginia 25, (8) LSU 24 (64.7%)
I didn't get to watch this game because my cable went out (more later), but all reviews are that LSU laid a real butt whoopin' on the Mountaineers. As predicted, the Tiger offense sputtered to 366 yards of total offense, which would rate them 83rd in the country on average. However, West Virginia provided four turnovers to the Tigers, and Tiger punter Brad Wing delivered with six kicks inside the WVU 15. All things considered, RBA predicted much of what happened. It just didn't account for how generous the Mountaineer offense and special teams would be.
Unstoppable Force/Immovable Object Game
Alabama Crimson Tide 38, Arkansas Razorbacks 14
Eddie
(2) Alabama 34, (13) Arkansas 21 (74.7%)
I told my wife, "Good news: The cable went out. Bad news: I'm happy about it." Alabama scored 21 points on special teams and defense. The Razorback defense held Trent Richardson and company to only 17 points, which is actually pretty good given that they were missing starting DEs Jake Bequette (hamstring) and Tenarius Wright (broken arm). The Hogs simply couldn't run the ball with Ronnie Wingo and take some pressure off Tyler Wilson. If Arkansas can slow down Alabama's running game, LSU should be able to do it. The question is if LSU can score on Alabama, either. We'll find out on November 5.
Justin
(1) Alabama 37, (12) Arkansas 29 (86.0%)
Apparently I over-estimated Arkansas' ability to score against Alabama. The Crimson Tide are scary good, and have a legitimate shot to displace LSU as SEC favorites and possibly even national championship favorites. The Razorbacks aren't bad by any stretch of the imagination, it was just that they ran into an absolute brick wall.
Shootout of the Week
Boise State Broncos 41, Tulsa Golden Hurricane 21
Justin
(2) Boise St. 43, (52) Tulsa 26 (93.2%)
Off by 2 (Boise) and 5 (Tulsa). I can live with this prediction. In the meantime I'll see about finding more interesting matchups in the coming weeks.
Eddie
(4) Boise St. 49, (59) Tulsa 17 (89.8%)
Poor, poor Tulsa. They scored 14 in the 4th quarter to make it respectable, but Boise State opened a can of whoop ass on them. The Broncos pulled Kellen Moore in the 3rd quarter and still hung 41 on the Golden Hurricane. They scored 34 before the Golden Hurricane sniffed the end zone. This game was every bit the shootout we expected it to be. I attribute the score difference to Boise State pulling their starters so early.
Coin Toss Game of the Week
North Texas Mean Green 24, Indiana Hoosiers 21
Eddie
(108) North Texas 31, (96) Indiana 28 (59.7%)
I'm not even going to pretend that I knew how this game was going to turn out. I sent a text message to Justin bragging that the Mean Green were leading 21-0 at the half and that I was well on my way to victory. Then, the Hoosiers went on a 21 point run in the 4th quarter. Needless to say, I'm happy to finally win a toss-up. Even with all the mess, RBA managed to get the exact margin of victory -- three points in favor of North Texas, 24-21.
Justin
(98) Indiana 36, (108) North Texas 35 (57.5%)
Chalk one up for RBA. Fortunately we split the other games on which our systems disagreed, 2-1 in my favor, so I didn't lose any more ground for the season tally. Plus I'm still up one in the coin toss games. On to next week!
The Tempo-Free Giridon is on the road this week, so the top 25 will be presented in abbreviated form. We'll be back up to speed later in the week.
Rank
+/-
Team
WinPct
SoS
Adjusted
Off.
Def.
Pace
1
--
Alabama
0.952
0.580
25
31.0
1
9.4
1
157.0
116
2
--
Boise St.
0.908
0.472
77
29.6
5
11.8
4
164.4
76
3
+3
Florida
0.906
0.521
48
27.8
9
11.3
2
163.1
83
4
-1
Stanford
0.902
0.501
59
30.7
2
12.6
6
160.3
101
5
--
LSU
0.893
0.682
2
29.7
4
12.7
8
160.5
99
6
-2
Oklahoma
0.886
0.662
6
25.8
15
11.3
3
180.7
3
7
+2
Wisconsin
0.868
0.480
72
29.9
3
14.1
14
159.1
107
8
-1
Ohio St.
0.857
0.472
78
24.9
19
12.2
5
157.9
112
9
+1
TCU
0.857
0.429
90
29.3
6
14.3
15
162.8
89
10
-2
Oregon
0.850
0.636
11
27.7
10
13.9
13
185.6
1
11
--
Virginia Tech
0.841
0.478
73
24.7
20
12.7
7
156.9
117
12
+2
Texas A&M
0.791
0.594
21
22.6
30
13.3
10
176.2
12
13
-1
Arkansas
0.781
0.611
17
27.8
8
16.7
34
166.7
53
14
-1
Florida St.
0.775
0.634
12
25.8
16
15.7
25
158.6
108
15
+2
Oklahoma St.
0.774
0.562
31
25.5
18
15.5
24
183.1
2
16
--
Utah
0.774
0.510
50
24.0
22
14.6
17
165.6
65
17
+1
Nebraska
0.771
0.495
63
24.4
21
15.0
22
165.6
67
18
NA
South Carolina
0.754
0.623
13
27.1
11
17.3
40
158.4
109
19
NA
Notre Dame
0.751
0.655
8
21.1
48
13.5
11
170.9
29
20
+4
Missouri
0.748
0.618
15
21.3
43
13.8
12
172.7
20
21
-1
Georgia
0.745
0.676
3
27.1
12
17.7
42
160.4
100
22
--
Texas
0.739
0.497
62
22.7
29
14.9
20
162.9
88
23
NA
Clemson
0.737
0.615
16
21.7
39
14.4
16
166.4
56
24
NA
Penn State
0.735
0.593
22
19.7
53
13.1
9
165.3
68
25
NA
Michigan St.
0.733
0.502
57
24.0
23
16.1
31
160.3
102
New entries: South Carolina, Notre Dame, Clemson, Penn State, Michigan St..
Dropped out: Miami-FL, Auburn, West Virginia, USC, Iowa.
Lots of churn throughout the polls this week, despite Eddie's claim that TFG's rankings are pretty static. Seven of the top 10 teams shifted around, even though their relative expected winning percentages didn't change much. Florida's absolute demolition of Kentucky keeps them in the top 5 this week, even as the Gators have yet to crack the top 10 in the human polls.
The true story here, though, is Alabama's utter dominance at the top of the polls. The Crimson Tide boast both the top offense and the top defense in the nation, but the 5th-slowest pace. Simply put, Alabama is scary right now. The are clear favorites in their remaining games and present a realistic chance to win the national championship in a little over three months.
In what many readers might point out as an oddity, Texas A&M remains ranked above Oklahoma State, even though the Cowboys defeated the Aggies. However, the game was extremely close and it wasn't truly over until the last minute. We're getting into the meat of the conference season now, and the quality of competition should really pick up. Can Florida hang with the other powers? Will anyone notice Boise? Can Alabama displace LSU in the minds of the voters? Only ten weeks until we have our answers.
Just a quick note to regular readers that I'm on the road this week and didn't have a chance to draft a Tuesday Trivia post. We don't want everyone to feel left out, so we'd like to take this moment to point everyone to some sites that pique our interest, including
Oddities abound in this week's RBA top 25. One-loss (3) Oregon jumps four spots over undefeated (4) Wisconsin and (5) Boise State thanks to a staggering offensive performance against Arizona. (8) Oklahoma drops three spots despite defeating (30) Missouri thanks to a lower-than-expected defensive performance. Meanwhile, (4) Texas A&M jumps four spots after losing to (10) Oklahoma State, who dropped a spot. RBA has a lot more poll mobility than TFG does, so we come to expect these things. The key to success in RBA's polls is sustained efficiency, exemplified by (1) Stanford and (2) Alabama. (3) Oregon, (4) Wisconsin, and (5) Boise State can contend for the top spot by improving their defenses.
Another Saturday, another 45 games. TFG and RBA disagree on four of these: OSU/Texas A&M, Indiana/North Texas, Virginia/Southern Miss., and West Virginia/LSU. We'll also see Boise State play Tulsa, a team that Oklahoma State played this past week; this'll give us one more "common opponent" data point to see how the Broncos stack up to BCS competition.