With only a few weeks to go in the season, the question appears to be "who will play Alabama in the title game?" The two obvious contenders are Notre Dame and Oregon. Based on their remaining schedules, though, TFG things the Fighting Irish are more than twice as likely to finish the regular season undefeated. These numbers don't take into account a conference championship, though; Notre Dame, of course, doesn't have one, and Alabama would be a 9-to-1 favorite against Florida (and a 22-to-1 favorite against Georgia). Oregon would be a 2-to-1 favorite against likely Pac-12 South champ USC.
Currently there's a 1-in-19 chance that Alabama, Notre Dame, and Oregon will all win out going into the championship game, at which point it will come down to style and strength of schedule. Notre Dame has the better SOS, but the Ducks have been making their case for a return to the title game. They'll need strong showings against Stanford, USC (possibly twice), and Oregon State in order to make their case.
Kansas State is still in the hunt, but TFG is still skeptical about their defense and remaining schedule. They're firmly in the "Long Shots" category.
I'd like to start by taking a few steps backwards before presenting the RBA top 25. The RBA top 25 is not a strict linear ordering of teams such that the (N-1)-th ranked team is expected to beat the N-th ranked team. It means that in aggregate, the (N-1)-th ranked team will win more games in a 124 team neutral field round robin than the N-th ranked team.
Alabama and Oregon remain the top two teams in the country, sporting the top defense and offense, respectively. RBA maintains a fairly consistent bias towards defensively-minded teams, so you'll find six of the top 10 defenses in the top 10. The only real WTF team in the top 15 is Oklahoma State at #7. They're sitting pretty thanks to an extremely consistent 22.2 +/- 0.8 PPH offense and an acceptably good-compared-to-most-of-the-Big-XII 8.3 +/- 9.5 PPH defense.
Dropped out: Mississippi St., Texas Tech, Penn State, Rutgers.
Alabama continues to steamroll their opposition, putting up 25.7 PPH against what was at the time the 14th-ranked defense in FBS. This follows performances of 29.5 PPH against the 71st-ranked defense (UT), and 27.8 PPH against the 17th-ranked defense (Missouri). The Crimson Tide are brutally efficient; at 41.1 PPH, they are a full 6.7 PPH better than Kansas State, the second-best offense in FBS.
Oregon is a bit of an anomaly, though. They rack up an amazing number of points, but often take their foot off the gas in the second or third quarter. We don't have a play-by-play breakdown, otherwise we'd have much better data for Oregon. Needless to say, the Ducks are definitely better than their TFG ranking indicates, but their actual ceiling is hard to find.
LSU continues to drift downwards (falling from a ranking of 0.932 takes time, especially when their defense continues to do a halfway decent job), while Notre Dame continues its climb up the rankings. The Fighting Irish are legitimately good this year, and it's all thanks to defense. Their offense continues to struggle; if they want to be a serious threat to Alabama in a title game, they absolutely positively have to jump at least 4.0 PPH to crack the top five.
Generally speaking, everything is pretty muddled. Alabama is dominating a difficult schedule, but everyone else is either dominating a middling schedule (e.g., Oregon), squeaking by a difficult schedule (e.g., Notre Dame), or some combination of the two (e.g., Kansas State, Ohio State, and Louisville).
Both our systems have a tendency to overrate Oklahoma. In RBA's case, it's not because they're super-efficient on offense. It's because they're consistently efficient at 27.1 +/- 7.7 PPH. If you can put up a reasonable number of points against everyone, you're most likely going to win. In contrast, the Irish struggle offensively against quality opposition, 32.4 +/- 24.2 PPH. That rarely matters thanks to their surprisingly good 9.7 +/- 2.1 PPH defense. Realistically, this game is going to come down to the matchup between Oklahoma's offense and Notre Dame's defense. The Irish can't afford to get into a shootout. If everything goes according to plan, Oklahoma silences the echoes, 27-20, with 52.7% confidence.
Coin Toss Game of the Week
Baylor Bears at Iowa State Cyclones
GUGS Score: 49.9
Eddie
Team
WinPct
SoS
Off.
Def.
Pace
74
Iowa St.
0.388
0.543
26
10.6
114
11.1
19
169.8
27
40
Baylor
0.681
0.563
3
25.2
3
20.6
104
173.4
10
Baylor's defense is a dreadful 7.6 +/- 25.9 PPH. The thing is that they can score at will with a 31.5 +/- 12.6 PPH offense. The Cyclones are going to have a hard time keeping up with the Bears. Sure, they beat TCU, but they scored only 9 points against Iowa, 13 against Texas Tech, and 10 against Oklahoma State, resulting in a 6.3 +/- 8.5 PPH offense. Their defense surrenders quite a few points, as well, suggesting that we're in for a shootout. RBA says Baylor in a very close one, 32-31, with 62.1% confidence.